Summer 2009 marked the 40th anniversary of the original Woodstock festival. Since that date the world has changed in more ways then one, but the event still has a large cultural impact to this day. That is probably why Taking Woodstock was created, but for a film with such nice timing it comes up shy in a few other aspects.
Ang Lee Still Finding Stride
When Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon (2000) was originally released Lee was heralded as the next big foreign born director. Since that time he directed an unpopular Hulk film (2003) and a critically acclaimed love story in Brokeback Mountain (2005).
Given that resume it would be hard to predict what Woodstock may look like. What Ang Lee chose to do was pay just enough homage to the original concert film's cinematography to draw comparisons but shy away from anything resembling a concert film. In fact the entire film plays out as more of a tease then anything else as the protagonist, Elliot Teichberg (played by Demetri Martin), never makes it to the stage. In fact, shots of the stage are rare and most of the classic music that made that show so important is missing.
Demetri Martin Stars, But is out Done by Jonathan Groff
Some of the attention for this film is undoubtedly coming from the fact that this is standup comedian Demetri Martin's first major motion picture. While Martin comes up with some great moments it is clear he probably was not ready to carry the whole film.
In Lee's defense he has commented that it is not a concert film, and it is possible that there was not enough money to get the rights to the songs. But, to not touch on any of the music, is a sort of bait and switch that leaves audience wanting. Even adding songs from bands that were not there to help with setting and feel would have been better than what was ultimately given.
On the other hand Broadway star Jonathan Groff turns in an excellent performance as Michael Lang, one of the organizers of the concert and a recognizable face from archival footage. While this is Groff's first film, he has been gaining popularity on the stage, even earning a Tony nomination in 2007. His performance seemed spot on and kept the film moving.
Watch the Original Film
Taking Woodstock is a decent film that is missing a few critical components. To get a real picture of the times, watch the original documentary which features all the performances in their gritty glory and has plenty of cultural commentary of its own. The inventive split screen cinematography, and cast of real people enjoying the show make it a must watch for every generation.
It will certainly leave you more satisfied than Lee's "Woodstock light" version.
 |
